Comparison and evaluation of several mobile-source and line-source models in Israel

This study compares several transportation-related air quality models. Two line-source models were used: Caline4 (California Department of Transportation) and Hiway2 (US Environmental Protection Agency). Two mobile-source models, Mobile5b (US Environmental Protection Agency) and COPERT3 (European Environment Agency), along with real-world emission factors were used and evaluated as well. Model predictions of NO_x concentrations were compared to measured values at two sites in Israel, differing by fleet composition and physical layout (‘at-grade’ and a ‘cut/depressed’ road sections). The process indicated that emission factors generated by COPERT3 are the most appropriate for free flowing traffic situations in Israel. Predictions by both line-source models were similar when applied to ‘at-grade’ road sections. When applied to ‘cut/depressed’ sections, Hiway2 better predicted concentrations during unstable conditions, while Caline4 better predicted concentrations during stable conditions and peak concentrations.