Evaluation of ramp control algorithms using microscopic traffic simulation

Ramp metering has emerged as an effective freeway control measure to ensure efficient freeway operations. A number of algorithms have been developed in recent years to ensure an effective use of ramp metering. As the performance of ramp metering depends on various factors (e.g. traffic volume, downstream traffic conditions, queue override policy etc), these algorithms should be evaluated under a wide range of traffic conditions to check their applicability and performance and to ensure their successful implementation. In view of the expenses of and confounding effects in field testing, simulation plays an important role in the evaluation of such algorithms. This paper presents an evaluation study of two ramp metering algorithms: ALINEA and FLOW. ALINEA is a local control algorithm and FLOW is an area wide coordinated algorithm. The purpose of the study is to use microscopic simulation to evaluate systematically how the level of traffic demand, queue spillback handling policy and downstream bottleneck conditions affect the performance of the algorithms. It is believed that these variables have complex interactions with ramp metering. MITSIM microscopic traffic simulator is used to perform the empirical study. The study consists of two stages. In the first stage, key input parameters for the algorithms were identified and calibrated. The calibrated parameters were then used for the second stage, where the performance of the algorithms were compared with respect to three traffic variables mentioned above using an orthogonal fraction of experiments. Regression analysis was used to identify the impacts of some of the interactions among experimental factors on the algorithms' performance, which is not otherwise possible with a tabular analysis. These results provide insights which may be helpful for design and calibration of more efficient ramp control algorithms.